The white Tiger by Arvind Adiga
( 1 ) How far do you agree with the India represented in the novel The White
Tiger ?
Ans. In the novel Balram him self said that he is Half baked Indian, so through this we can see that Adiga portrays various realistic and graphic picture of some of the most drastic and bitter facts of India. But he well said that the narrator is half baked Indian so we can’t believe hundred present on it. As per M.Q. Khan said it is about Adiga’s India but it is not everybody’s India. He does not bring out the whole of India. Because on the other side some good soul , good persons, truth and honesty are there. But in novel he criticize various aspects of Indian society like Education, Indian traditional marriage, politics, Religion, Land lords, corruption and culture etc.
( 2 ) Do you believe that Balram’s story is the archetype of all stories of ‘rags to riches’?
Ans. Yes, Balram’s story is become the archetype of all stories but We can say only 30 to 40 percent people can follow same thing like Balram did specially in the era of Post truth. People can take as new morality like Balram said. But other can also become a good and well known person in society through the hard work, think out of box, intelligence and some time may be luck. For ex – In slumdog millionaire movie Jamal became rich. Because people of India wants to become reach any way and that’s why they used lottery tickets or this kind of shows also.
( 3 ) "Language bears within itself the necessity of its own critique, deconstructive criticism aims to show that any text inevitably undermines its own claims to have a determinate meaning, and licences the reader to produce his own meanings out of it by an activity of semantic 'freeplay' (Derrida, 1978, in Lodge, 1988, p. 108). Is it possible to do deconstructive reading of The White Tiger ? How?
Ans. Yes, this text can be deconstructed well. Here is one So here we can say that Balram himself say that he is half baked Indian and author him self said at starting point that – “ This book is Auto – Biography of half – baked Indians”, so how we can believe on his all criticism of dark India. Because he knows only through his own experience. So it’s very narrow views not wider one.
“Me, and thousands of others in this country like me, are half-baked, because we were never allowed to complete our schooling. Open our skulls, look in with a penlight, and you'll find an odd museum of ideas: sentences of history or mathematics remembered from school textbooks (no boy remembers his schooling like one who was taken out of school, let me assure you), sentences about politics read in a newspaper while waiting for someone to come to an office, triangles and pyramids seen on the torn pages of the old geometry textbooks which every tea shop in this country uses to wrap its snacks in, bits of All India Radio news bulletins, things that drop into your mind, like liz huards from the ceiling, in the half hour before falling asleep—all these ideas, half formed and half digested and half correct, mix up with other half-cooked ideas in your head, and I guess these half-formed ideas bugger one another, and make more half-formed ideas, and this is what you act on and live with. The story of my upbringing is the story of how a half-baked fellow is produced.”
(4 )With ref to screening of the Netflix adaptation:
1. write review of the film adaptation of The White Tiger
Ans. Balram Halwai the protagonist ironically hails from a village named Laxmangarh, kyunki a all he wants to do is not follow his elder brother . After he's made to quit school to repay his family debt, instead wants to live up to his own elder brother name . Soon he lies his way into a job as a driver at the village's most affluent man's homs. Gradually he learns more about the privilege eavesdrops on conversations and through acute observations figures out various ways to denounce his older life and works towards the life he aspirs. As much as Balram wants to up his stature in society he is just as desperate to leave his past behind.and you know not behind in an underdog way, somebody . Who would overcome obstacles but behind in a way. That at this point he stopped who dies. Which here can be interested in two ways one which says . That modern India chasm between the have's and have nots is so wide, there no instional way to bridge and information to make up your own own mind about all the characters you are seeing on screen. There's enough opportunity to enter the scenery and check biases by finding your reflection in people on display.
Ashok and pinky the rich masters with the most common names, lives high above in a tall to tower, whereas Balram curls up on dusty mattress in the basement, not allowed to go up unless summned.
2. Have you identified any difference in the novel and the addpation ? Does it make any significant difference in the overall tone and texture of the novel ?
Ans. We can find same Narrative in the novel and the movie . In novel and movie both are using different kind of gymic. As in movie Jamal is describing with #KBC show. In novel Balram is reading poster one by one and he is seeing some wanted pictures as he kills his master. But when we look into the movie,than Jamal is very brilliant, intelligent and fast observer boy. When he is giving answer than it opens some pages of his past, story is folding with some new kind of chapter.Both Narration goes parreral as both are talking about India and it's culture or history. Novel and movie both reaches on their top and trying to showing us best.
3. David Ehrani's in his review write this - Ramin Bahrani's Netflix Triller is a Brutal corrective to ' slumdog millionaire' is it a corrective what was the error in slumdog millionaire that it is corrected ?
1)Narrative structure :
The Novel and the film has almost similar structure. Both works starts with flashback techniques. In the film used one reality show KBC in which question and answer session going on. All the questions leads Jamal into his past. While in the novel wanted poster used. By using this poster writer talking about his past.The narrative structure was first person narrative.
Indianness :
Train is also found in both the works. It shows the Indianness in the work.It is a symbol of poverty and crowd.Train shows middle class position .
Curruption :
Curruption can be found in both works. In the novel talking about Currupt nature of entrepreneur's drivers. In the film shows Currupt nature of Jamal 's brother. He was getting more money from tourist.Anchor of KBC show do cheating by telling answer to Jamal.Nowadays Curruption also part of India.This way we see Indianness in these works.
Religion :
Religion is also important element of Novel and film. In the novel described the darker side of religion.And in the film we had seen Hindu Muslim riot which creates problem in the Area ,criticism of 'Darshan do Ghanshyam' song . This way people use Religion.Indian people blindly believe in religion that we seen in both the works.
Religion :
Education system :
Both the protagonist Jamal ( Film) and Balaram ( Novel ) are uneducated. In the novel shows darker and Currupt side of education system. It shows the darker side of India. Jamal could not able to study.
Poverty :
In the film shows the largest slum area of Asia Dharavi which located in India. Both the works based on the life of poor peoples struggle. Both works criticised poverty as the darker side of India.Both protagonists believes that if you want to become rich you must do wrong things.
In the novel poetic justice not happened by punishing the Balram. He murdered his master yet not caught by police. While in the film poetic justice happened when salim committed suicide at the end and Jamal became popular and rich. Both the work differs from each other on the Bases of treatment given to wrong people.
Thanks...✍️